Welcome to the 77th edition of our Newsletter EdGenie's 📜 Sunday Scroll...
Every Sunday I send out actionable tips, tricks and real-world application insights from my 15 year experience coaching students to achieve As and A*s in their Economics A Levels via EdGenie.
Jump to Section:
Data Response is 75% of your exam. Can you afford to mess it up?
NHS may need private funding to fix buildings, says head of England’s health service
Infographic of the Week
Chart of the Week
Macroeconomic Data
Data Response is 75% of your exam. Can you afford to mess it up?
🏥 NHS Infrastructure Crisis: NHS England chief Amanda Pritchard warns of the highest maintenance backlog on record, with outdated buildings and technology.
💰 Call for Private Investment: Pritchard suggests that private capital must be considered to address the NHS’s crumbling infrastructure.
🚫 Past Issues with Private Finance: Private Finance Initiatives (PFIs) were scrapped in 2018 due to high debt burdens and poor taxpayer value, but some local authorities continue using them.
📉 Funding Shortfall: A government review found that between 2010 and 2020, England spent £37bn less on health infrastructure than peer countries, worsening the maintenance crisis.
🏚️ Urgent Repairs Needed: The NHS’s maintenance backlog has reached £13.8bn, forcing budget reallocations from capital investments to day-to-day expenses.
🏗️ Alternative Models Explored: NHS Confederation suggests looking at Wales' Mutual Investment Model and other public-private partnerships for infrastructure renewal.
📜 Government's 10-Year Plan: Any changes in capital spending are expected in the government’s upcoming long-term NHS plan, set to be unveiled in spring.
🔄 New Private Investment Approach: NHS leaders stress that this is not a return to the old PFI model but a search for a new, sustainable funding solution.
A Level Economics Questions:
Q. Explain why the NHS is considered a merit good and how this impacts government intervention in its funding.
A. The NHS is a merit good because it provides positive externalities, meaning the social benefits of healthcare exceed private benefits. Without government intervention, the NHS would be under-consumed as individuals may undervalue its long-term benefits. Market failure occurs if healthcare is left to the private sector, as those unable to pay would be excluded. The government funds the NHS through progressive taxation to ensure universal access, improving public health, workforce productivity, and economic efficiency. However, funding constraints often lead to capital investment shortfalls, requiring debate over private sector involvement.
Q. Explain how a lack of capital investment in public infrastructure, such as NHS buildings, can lead to market failure.
A. Capital investment in the NHS ensures high-quality service provision and efficiency. A lack of investment in infrastructure leads to dilapidated hospitals, outdated technology, and inefficiencies, reducing service quality and increasing waiting times. This can create negative externalities, such as worsening public health and lower productivity. Market failure occurs because the NHS is a public service, and insufficient funding results in allocative inefficiency, where resources are not used effectively. Without adequate investment, long-term healthcare costs rise, creating additional pressure on government finances.
Q.Discuss whether public-private partnerships (PPPs) are an effective alternative to government funding for public services such as healthcare.
A. PPPs allow private firms to finance, build, and manage public services, reducing immediate pressure on government budgets. They can improve efficiency by using private sector expertise, ensuring projects are delivered on time and within budget. However, long-term contracts may create financial burdens, as seen in PFI hospital projects, where excessive debt reduced NHS spending flexibility. Government borrowing is often cheaper than private sector finance, making PPPs less cost-effective in the long run. While PPPs can supplement funding gaps, they must be carefully regulated to ensure value for money and public accountability.
Q. Private sector involvement in public healthcare funding leads to inefficiencies and higher costs in the long run.” To what extent do you agree?
A.The private sector can bring investment, innovation, and efficiency to public healthcare funding, reducing short-term financial strain on the government. However, past experiences, such as PFIs, show that private financing can lead to long-term inefficiencies, as profit-seeking behaviour may increase overall costs. Private firms often charge higher interest rates, leading to debt accumulation and diverting resources from frontline care. While private sector involvement may be beneficial in specific cases, a fully privatised approach risks reducing accessibility and worsening health inequalities. A mixed model with government oversight may offer the best balance.
Possible A Level Economics 25 Marker Question
Evaluate the impact of underinvestment in NHS infrastructure on the UK’s long-term economic growth and productivity. (25 marks)
Infographic of the Week
The EU Economy: Strength Amidst Stagnation
The European Union, with a combined GDP of $19.4 trillion in 2024, remains a global economic powerhouse despite uneven growth. Germany, France, and Italy continue to dominate, contributing 53% of the total GDP, though they faced stagnation or contraction. Spain and the Netherlands complete the top five, bringing their collective share to 68%. Germany alone outproduces the 20 smallest EU economies combined. While Malta recorded the highest growth at 5%, it remains the bloc’s smallest economy. If the UK were still part of the EU, its $4.4 trillion GDP would make it the second-largest economy after Germany.
Chart of the Week
The Gender Gap in Care Work
Care-related professions remain highly gendered, with women dominating roles in childcare, nursing, midwifery, and domestic work. According to the International Labour Organization, an estimated 708 million women globally are outside the labour force due to unpaid care responsibilities, reinforcing the disparity in caregiving roles. Women continue to bear the burden of child-rearing, housekeeping, and long-term care, highlighting the persistent gender imbalance in both paid and unpaid care work.
Macroeconomic Data
Whenever you're ready there is one way I can help you.
If you or your child are looking to Boost your A level Economics Grades in under 30 days, I'd recommend starting with an all-in-one support network where you get 24/7 access to a SuperTutor:
→ Join EdGenie 🧞♂️: Transform your A-Level Economics essays and exam marks (genuinely) with our comprehensive on-demand learning platform. This carefully curated course blends engaging content with effective exam techniques, the same ones that have empowered over 1,000 of my students to achieve an A or A* over the last 13 years.
A huge thanks for hopping on board EdGenie's Wednesday Wisdoms newsletter!
I'm Emre, and I've got a big goal - to make A* education accessible to all A-level students.
And it Starts With You!
Emre Aksahin
Chief Learning Officer at Edgenie
Join EdGenie 🧞♂️
Unlock Full Access to Examinable Questions and Answers, Plus: